As usual, after sleeping for a good 8 hours, I decided that I couldn't live with the messed up toe, LOL! Its amazing what you can live with when you've been up all night. I did this with another project I was working on during the over-night shift and after sleeping decided to go back and fix it. Live and learn!
I ripped it out:
Then I did it correctly. I moved the markers around so that they were in the middle of the stitches and added two decrease rounds to come back to the number of stitches in the original pattern.
I am MUCH happier with this! Here's a close up of the pattern stitch: